Reflection

Professional Reflection

A critical examination of my nursing practice, clinical growth, and the experiences that have shaped my professional identity as I work toward AHPRA registration.

ICU Case Study

Communication With a Mechanically Ventilated Patient

The following case study reflects on my experience of caring for an awake mechanically ventilated patient who was struggling to communicate. To maintain confidentiality, no identifying information has been included.

Introduction

Communication is an important part of nursing care, especially in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU), where patients may be critically unwell and unable to communicate in their usual way. Patients who are mechanically ventilated through an endotracheal tube may be awake and aware of their surroundings but unable to speak. This can lead to frustration, anxiety, fear, and a reduced sense of control (Holm et al., 2020; Karlsen et al., 2023).

Research shows that different communication strategies, such as gestures, writing, communication boards, and other augmentative and alternative communication methods, can support mechanically ventilated patients to express their needs more effectively (Kuruppu et al., 2023; Zaga et al., 2019). This case study reflects on my experience of caring for an awake mechanically ventilated patient who was struggling to communicate.

Case Background

During one of my shifts in the ICU, I cared for an adult patient who had been admitted with severe respiratory failure and required intubation and mechanical ventilation. The patient had been in ICU for several days and, as their condition started to improve, their sedation was gradually reduced.

The patient became more awake and aware of what was happening around them, but they were still unable to speak because of the endotracheal tube. Patients in this situation can experience significant communication difficulties, particularly when they are conscious but unable to express their needs verbally (Holm et al., 2020).

The patient continued to require respiratory support, continuous monitoring, medications, and close nursing care. To maintain confidentiality, no identifying information has been included in this case study.

Presenting Situation

During my assessment, I noticed that the patient appeared anxious and restless. They were repeatedly moving their hands, attempting to mouth words, and trying to gain my attention.

Their observations were generally stable, although their heart rate increased when they became more distressed. Initially, I considered whether the restlessness was related to pain, discomfort, hypoxia, or delirium.

However, after observing the patient more closely, I realised that their movements appeared purposeful. It became clear that they were trying to communicate something to me. Communication difficulties in mechanically ventilated patients can cause frustration and emotional distress, especially when patients are unable to make themselves understood by staff or family members (Holm et al., 2020; Karlsen et al., 2023).

Nursing Assessment

I completed a focused assessment of the patient's airway, breathing, oxygen saturation, circulation, level of consciousness, pain, and overall comfort.

Once I was satisfied that there was no immediate clinical deterioration, I focused more closely on the patient's communication needs. I approached the patient calmly and explained that I understood they were unable to speak. I asked simple yes-or-no questions and encouraged them to respond by nodding, shaking their head, or squeezing my hand.

The patient responded appropriately, which showed that they understood what I was saying and were able to participate in communication. This experience reminded me that communication methods need to be adapted to the individual patient. A patient's ability to communicate may depend on their level of consciousness, physical strength, fatigue, and ability to use communication aids (Karlsen et al., 2023; Kuruppu et al., 2023).

Nursing Intervention

I provided the patient with a communication board and a pen. At first, the patient found it difficult to write because they were weak and tired. I could see that they were becoming frustrated, so I reassured them and gave them more time rather than rushing the interaction.

After several attempts, the patient was able to communicate that they were worried about their family. This was an important moment for me because I realised that their distress was not only related to their physical condition. They were also experiencing fear and uncertainty because they could not easily ask about the people who were important to them.

I reassured the patient and discussed their concern with the senior nurse and relevant members of the healthcare team. Following the appropriate process and considering the patient's wishes, communication with the family was facilitated.

During the rest of my shift, I continued to use a combination of yes-or-no questions, gestures, writing, and the communication board. Evidence suggests that augmentative and alternative communication tools can help mechanically ventilated patients express their needs and participate more actively in communication, although the method should be suited to the individual patient (Kuruppu et al., 2023). Communication interventions have also been found to be useful and feasible within ICU settings (Zaga et al., 2019).

Outcome

After the patient was able to communicate their concern, I noticed a clear change in their behaviour. They became calmer and less restless and appeared more comfortable. They were also able to communicate some of their basic needs more effectively throughout the remainder of the shift.

The communication board was a simple intervention, but it gave the patient an opportunity to express something that was very important to them. Research supports the use of communication strategies to improve interaction between mechanically ventilated patients and healthcare professionals (Kuruppu et al., 2023; Zaga et al., 2019).

I documented the communication approach in the nursing notes and included it in my handover so that the next nurse could continue using the same method.

Reflection

This experience reminded me that ICU nursing is not only about managing ventilators, medications, observations, and medical equipment. It is also about recognising the person behind all of that technology.

At first, my main focus was on identifying a clinical cause for the patient's restlessness. This was important, as problems such as pain, hypoxia, or delirium needed to be considered. However, I learned that I also needed to look beyond the monitor and pay attention to what the patient was trying to communicate. Mechanically ventilated patients can experience frustration and vulnerability when they are unable to speak, even when they are fully aware of their surroundings (Holm et al., 2020).

This experience also changed the way I think about restlessness in critically ill patients. I learned that not all restlessness is simply agitation. Sometimes the patient may be frightened, uncertain, uncomfortable, or trying unsuccessfully to communicate an important need.

Karlsen et al. (2023) describe communication with mechanically ventilated patients as a complex process influenced by the patient, the healthcare professional, the environment, and the communication method being used. This reinforced for me that communication needs to be individualised.

The experience also strengthened my understanding of patient advocacy. My patient could not use their voice in the usual way, but they still had concerns, preferences, and emotions that needed to be recognised. As their nurse, part of my responsibility was to find another way for them to be heard.

References

  1. Holm, A., Dreyer, P., & Tjørnhøj-Thomsen, T. (2020). Nurses' experiences of communication with patients who are conscious and mechanically ventilated in the intensive care unit. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 29(3–4), 619–628. https://doi.org/10.1111/jocn.15120
  2. Karlsen, M. W., Ølnes, M. A., & Heyn, L. G. (2023). Communication with patients in intensive care units: A scoping review. Nursing in Critical Care, 28(1), 5–14. https://doi.org/10.1111/nicc.12608
  3. Kuruppu, C., Bhatt, J., Bhatt, M., & Bhatt, N. (2023). Augmentative and alternative communication in the intensive care unit: A systematic review. Intensive and Critical Care Nursing, 74, 103327. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.iccn.2022.103327
  4. Zaga, C. J., Berney, S., & Vogel, A. P. (2019). The feasibility, utility, and safety of communication interventions with mechanically ventilated intensive care unit patients: A systematic review. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 28(3), 1335–1355. https://doi.org/10.1044/2019_AJSLP-18-0244

Reflective Practice Video

A personal reflection on my nursing journey, clinical experiences, and professional development goals.

Professional reflection — Udani Rathnayaka, Master of Nursing

Written Reflection — Gibbs' Reflective Cycle

The following reflection uses Gibbs' Reflective Cycle to examine a significant experience from my clinical placement in a residential aged-care facility. For confidentiality, the resident is referred to as Mr Adam.

During my clinical placement in a residential aged-care facility, I had an experience with a resident that made me think more deeply about dignity, independence and person-centred care. For confidentiality, I will refer to the resident as Mr Adam. I have used Gibbs' Reflective Cycle to guide this reflection because reflection can help nurses recognise what went well, what could be improved and how future practice can change (Barchard, 2022).

1. Description

During an early morning shift, I was allocated to assist Mr Adam with his activities of daily living, including showering, dressing and getting ready for breakfast. From handover, I knew that he usually liked to do as much as possible for himself and that staff were encouraged to support his independence.

When I entered his room, Mr Adam was already awake and sitting on the edge of his bed. I introduced myself and explained that I was there to help him get ready for the day. He looked at me and said, 'I don't need help. I can do it myself.' I was unsure how to respond because I had been told during handover that he needed assistance with personal care.

I felt uncertain and a little anxious. I was aware that I needed to complete my allocated tasks within a certain timeframe, but I also did not want to dismiss what Mr Adam was telling me. I was concerned about what would happen if I left him to manage on his own and something went wrong.

Looking back, I think I initially focused too much on completing the task rather than listening to what Mr Adam was communicating. He was expressing a clear preference about how he wanted to be cared for, and I almost overrode that because of time pressure and uncertainty.

What went well was that I did pause and take a moment to listen to him. I asked Mr Adam what he felt comfortable doing on his own and what he would like help with. He told me he could manage his upper body wash and dressing but would appreciate help with his lower body and footwear because of his limited mobility.

This small adjustment made a significant difference. Mr Adam became more relaxed and cooperative. He thanked me at the end of the interaction and said he appreciated that I had listened to him. I felt that we had worked together rather than me simply performing a task on him.

2. Feelings

Person-centred care means recognising the individual's values, preferences and needs and involving them in decisions about their own care (McCormack & McCance, 2017). In this situation, I had to balance the clinical information from handover with what Mr Adam was telling me directly. I realise now that his verbal refusal was not simply resistance — it was an expression of his autonomy and his desire to maintain control over his own body and daily routine.

Dignity in care is closely connected to how much control a person feels they have over their own life (Baillie, 2009). For older adults in residential care, maintaining independence in activities of daily living, even partially, can be important for their sense of self-worth and wellbeing.

3. Evaluation

I also reflected on the role of communication in this situation. If I had proceeded without asking Mr Adam what he wanted, I would have undermined his dignity and potentially damaged the therapeutic relationship. Effective communication is a core nursing competency and is essential for delivering person-centred care (Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia, 2016).

One area I could have improved was my initial response. When Mr Adam first said he did not need help, I hesitated rather than responding calmly and confidently. In future, I would like to be more skilled at acknowledging a patient's preferences immediately and opening a collaborative conversation from the start.

4. Analysis

I would also like to develop a better understanding of how to balance clinical risk with patient autonomy. There are situations where a patient's preference may conflict with safety considerations, and I want to be better prepared to navigate those conversations in a respectful and evidence-based way.

This experience has reinforced my commitment to person-centred care as a core value in my nursing practice. I now approach personal care interactions with a greater awareness of the importance of asking rather than assuming, and of recognising that the patient is always the expert on their own experience.

I have also become more aware of how time pressure in clinical settings can sometimes work against person-centred care. While efficiency is important, it should not come at the cost of a patient's dignity or autonomy. Finding ways to work efficiently while still taking the time to listen is something I continue to reflect on.

Following this experience, I discussed the interaction with my clinical supervisor, who affirmed my approach and encouraged me to continue developing my communication skills. I also reviewed the facility's person-centred care policy and the relevant sections of the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia's Registered Nurse Standards for Practice.

In future practice, I will continue to use Gibbs' Reflective Cycle as a tool for examining my clinical experiences. I find it helpful because it encourages me to move beyond simply describing what happened and to think critically about why I responded the way I did and how I can improve.

This experience with Mr Adam was a valuable reminder that nursing is fundamentally about people. The technical skills and clinical knowledge are essential, but they must always be applied in a way that respects the individuality, dignity and autonomy of each person in our care.

5. Conclusion

Reflection is not always comfortable. It requires honesty about moments of uncertainty and areas for growth. But I believe that this kind of honest self-examination is what separates competent nurses from truly excellent ones, and it is a practice I am committed to throughout my career.

The experience also highlighted the importance of the therapeutic relationship in nursing. Mr Adam's willingness to communicate his preferences with me was only possible because he felt safe enough to do so. Building that trust, even in a brief interaction, is something I now consciously work toward in every patient encounter.

6. Action Plan

I am grateful for this experience and for what it taught me about listening, dignity and the meaning of person-centred care. It is one of the interactions I will carry with me as I continue to develop as a nurse and work toward AHPRA registration.

References

  1. Baillie, L. (2009). Patient dignity in an acute hospital setting: A case study. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 46(1), 23–37. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2008.08.003
  2. Barchard, G. (2022). Reflective practice in nursing. In J. Crisp, C. Douglas, G. Rebeiro, & D. Waters (Eds.), Potter & Perry's fundamentals of nursing (6th ed., pp. 112–125). Elsevier.
  3. McCormack, B., & McCance, T. (2017). Person-centred practice in nursing and health care: Theory and practice (2nd ed.). Wiley-Blackwell.
  4. Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia. (2016). Registered nurse standards for practice. https://www.nursingmidwiferyboard.gov.au/Codes-Guidelines-Statements/Professional-standards/registered-nurse-standards-for-practice.aspx
  5. Timmins, F., & Duffy, A. (2011). Writing your nursing portfolio: A step-by-step guide. Open University Press.

E-Poster Presentation

A visual summary of clinical evidence and nursing practice insights.

E-Poster: Preventing Falls, Protecting Lives — Udani Rathnayaka
E-Poster: Preventing Falls, Protecting Lives — Udani Rathnayaka